ANT 570

Papers

Home

Here are the papers for review.  They are in Adobe Acrobat (pdf) format.  You will need to create a document for each of your reviews and send all three review documents to me (e-mail) and send each review to the author of the paper (e-mail addresses below).

In reviewing the papers, do not worry about the formatting as it gets scrambled somewhat by the word plug-in to Internet Explorer.  Also, you can assume that I will pick up most typos and grammatical errors.  You do not need to catalog these unless they just jump off the page and annoy you (like they do for me).  You should concentrate your review on seeing how well the paper accomplishes the purpose stated by the author.  You may want to review our paper rules now, so that you can emphasize comments about rules 1 through 5 noting organization, logic and logical flow, use of information from citations, figures, tables, and the like.  In commenting on specific elements of the paper you should note the page, paragraph(s), and line(s) wherever appropriate as: 

{EXAMPLE: Page 4, paragraph 2, lines 4-10  The point about eating too much taro was not clear.  You may want to give an example, cite the actual grams per day of consumption, or find other sources to bolster your point}.

The reviews are due (to me and to the authors) before class on November 23  

These files are acrobat documents.  You can open them in your browser [left click] or right-click on the link to pop up the menu that includes the choice "Save Target As" to copy them to your disk.  In reviewing the papers, be sure to focus on content, logic, clarity, and completeness.  Review them critically as you did in reviewing the studies for your own paper.  E-mail your reviews to the author and to me.

Paper (pdf)

e-mail

Reviewer 1

Reviewer 2

Reviewer 3

Campbell

Campbell

Destefano

Lowe

Whitehead

Destefano

Destefano

Persons

Campbell

Wyman

Lowe

Lowe

Campbell

Whitehead

Persons

Persons

Persons

Whitehead

Wyman

Lowe

Whitehead

Whitehead

Wyman

Destefano

Campbell

Wyman

Wyman

Lowe

Persons

Destefano

Sample Papers from Previous Classes

The Biocultural Evolution of Birth

The Black Jews of South Africa

Chopping Down the Family Tree

New World Paleoepidemiology

Social Effects on Cardiovascular Disease in Brazil